New Scary Movies On Prime May 2026

Set within a Jewish funeral home in Brooklyn, this one takes a forgotten piece of mythology—the Abyzou, a demonic child-stealer—and turns it into 90 minutes of claustrophobic terror. Think Hereditary meets The Possession . The scares are patient, the atmosphere is thick, and the final act doesn’t let go of your throat.

Viewers who liked The Boogeyman and want something meaner. 3. The Passenger (2023) Vibe: Relentless road rage horror

From the directors of Goodnight Mommy , this Austrian period horror follows a devout woman in 1750 whose depression is mistaken for demonic possession. There are no cheap scares—only an encroaching, gray misery that culminates in one of the most disturbing finales of the year. animal harm and self-harm. new scary movies on prime

While more of a thriller-hybrid, this film earns its horror badge through pure, sweaty tension. After a workplace shooting, a mild-mannered janitor is kidnapped by his volatile co-worker for a sunrise road trip of carnage. It’s less supernatural, more you-can’t-look-away dread. Kyle Gallner delivers a career-best unhinged performance.

A dying man turns to an ancient, cursed relic in a desperate attempt to save his wife. You can guess how that goes. What makes this one sting is the raw emotional core beneath the shaky-cam chaos. The “bag” doesn’t just kill—it warps reality, turning memories into nightmares. Set within a Jewish funeral home in Brooklyn,

People who think The Hitcher wasn’t stressful enough. 4. Dark Windows (2023) Vibe: Teen slasher with a summer camp hangover

Fans of religious horror and jump scares that earn their keep. 2. Bag of Lies (2024) Vibe: Found footage, but make it grief-stricken Viewers who liked The Boogeyman and want something meaner

If you’ve been scrolling through Amazon Prime Video looking for something to raise the hairs on your neck, you’re in luck. The streamer just added a fresh crop of horror that ranges from psychological slow-burns to full-throttle gore-fests. Here’s what’s new and actually worth your nightlight. 1. The Offering (2024) Vibe: Folklore dread meets family trauma